Russia stumbles in “post-Soviet space”?

In case you have been following the conflict between Russia and Belarus: the “milk wars” (the Russian ban on imports of Belarussian dairy products, followed by the imposition of harsh new customs tariffs on Russian roducts in Belarus) are over.  Now, it seems there’s a gas war coming.  Belarus’s wily authoritarian leader, Alexander Lukashenko (popularly known as “bat’ka” — a folsky and rather affectionate term best translated as “Big Daddy”), canceled his presence at a summit on security issues in a fit of pique.  What it’s really about is the fact that nearly a year ago, Russia gave Belarus a $500 million loan with the tacit understanding that it was the first of installments in a bribe for recognizing Russia’s new client states, Abkhazia and South Ossetia.  Big Daddy, who has been playing a skillful game of seduction with both Russia and Western Europe. took the money and bailed on the two republics.  Russia refused to cough up the second installment of the bribe.

There are no good guys in this clash: Belarus is an authoritarian state that, in many ways, makes Russia look like a beacon of freedom, and Bat’ka Lukashenko is a clever thug.  Nonetheless, this latest row underscores the fact that Russia’s power in the “post-Soviet space” it likes to claim as its sphere of “privileged interests” is not nearly as great as it is often made out to be — even if the Kremlin still has the ability to throw money around (in a crisis!) to give another neighboring state the incentive to kick out a U.S. air force base.   Russia’s crude manner of swinging its weight around — in response to Lukashenko’s show of defiance, a senior Medvedev Administration official told Kommersant newspaper, commenting on the situation in Belarus, that “apparently, someone has had enough of being president of that country” — has contributed to its problems.

In this excellent Russian-language article on, the astute Russian policy analyst Stanislav Belkovsky notes that in the past decade, “the Kremlin has done everything it could to squander the remnants of its influence in its former empire” and to quarrel with precisely those neighbors with whom it most needs good relations.

(Cross-posted to


Filed under Russia

2 responses to “Russia stumbles in “post-Soviet space”?

  1. Philip Melita

    Dear Ms. Young:

    The scales between so-called left and right or liberal and conservative are not even remotely in balance. Where are your examples of Beck’s and Limbaugh’s “trafficking in political paranoia and hate”? I’m sorry, but there is no comparison to the vitriol spewing from the herd on the left who, by the way, began the foul-mouthed discourse and ad hominen attacks a generation ago. The so-called right wing rarely responds anywhere near in kind.

    P.A. Melita
    Charlottesville, VA

  2. Dear Mr. Melita:

    First of all, you made your comment on the wrong post. Secondly — Glenn Beck, for one, has repeated rumors about FEMA concentration camps (which he admittedly debunked later). Examples of Limbaugh trafficking in hate are too numerous to cite here, but calling Tom Daschle “Hanoi Tom” and “Tokyo Tom” a few years ago (and then going on a riff about Daschle being “the devil”) is a pretty strong one. The amusing part, of course, is that people from the left are just as convinced that “there is no comparison.”

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s