One Muslim voice on the Holocaust, unheard

The lovely gathering of Holocaust deniers in Tehran, spiced up by the attedance of former KKK wizard and Republican pol manqué David Duke and (compounding the theater of the absurd) of a group of anti-Zionist rabbis, has gotten a lot of attention and has been roundly condemned. But the media have missed this fascinating story, reported in today’s Forward:

Khaled Kasab Mahameed waited until the very last moment, hoping that his visa would come through. A Muslim lawyer from the Israeli Arab city of Nazareth, he had reserved a seat on an afternoon flight December 10 from Amman to Tehran, expecting to address Iran’s international conference on the Holocaust. His bag was packed. His wife and two children were ready to take him at 9:00 a.m. to the Jordanian border crossing.

But at 9:00 a.m., his hopes were dashed. In a phone call to the Iranian Embassy in Amman, a clerk informed him that there was no visa waiting for him. “I was so disappointed,” he said. “I sat depressed, and I waited an hour and called again. Then another hour and called again. In the end, they said Israelis don’t get visas.”

Mahameed, 44, had been waiting for this day from the moment he received his invitation to the conference from Iran’s Foreign Ministry. In 2005, Mahameed opened the world’s first Holocaust museum for Arabs, called the Arab Institute for Holocaust Research and Education. It shares a floor with his law office.

In a way, the conference was his moment of truth. Not only would Mahameed have an international platform to teach Muslims and Arabs about the Holocaust — and possibly to get more financial support for his work. More important, in his opinion, he finally would be listened to. For the first time, he had been invited by Muslims to speak about his views. And maybe, just maybe, he could convince some to open their minds and hearts — to Jewish pain.

But it was not to be. “I thought about it,” he said, “maybe they invited me because they thought I live in the Palestinian Authority.”

Mahameed, an Israeli Arab whose family lost its land to a kibbutz when the State of Israel was created, is sympathetic to Palestinian claims. However, his approach to the subject is a unique one:

“When you don’t understand the Holocaust, it hinders the peace process,” he said. “I wanted to go tell the Iranians that when you play down the Holocaust or deny it, you are directly hurting the Palestinian refugees who are in camps. By denying it, they are making the Jewish people feel persecuted — which doesn’t allow options for peace to develop.”

“Ninety percent of the Israeli identity is based on the experience of the Holocaust — the horrors of the Nazis,” Mahameed said. “So when [the Iranians] deny the Holocaust, they are actually saying [Palestinians] are facing something that doesn’t exist. But it does exist.”

Mahameed’s knowledge is expansive, quoting from Heine and Clausewitz. But his focus is very much at home — directed at the conflict that affects his own life.

“I remember since I was 6, my father always said we are paying for the horrors of the Holocaust.”

Almost counter-intuitively, Mahameed argues that the Palestinians cannot win by talking of Israeli atrocities, but rather by acknowledging the atrocities perpetuated against the Jews.

“Palestinians talk about Israelis killing 1,000 or 2,000 in Sabra and Shatila,” he said, referring to a massacre that happened under Israeli watch after the 1982 Lebanon War. “But the Israelis have 6 million. I say, Palestinians need to adopt the Holocaust. The result of adopting the Holocaust is that then they don’t need to be violent against the Jews. That’s the power of the Holocaust. So let’s bring information to the Palestinians about the Holocaust.”

But he also believes that Jews need to make an effort: “I also request from the Jews to overcome the Holocaust. Yes, it was a horror, but why let Hitler continue to dictate our lives?”

He blames Israelis and Europeans for not teaching Arabs and Muslims about the Holocaust. “Israelis always speak of the need to preserve the security of the Jewish state. Why not explain why? Why not describe what happened to the Jews in the Holocaust so the Arabs will understand that the Holocaust is an important factor in shaping policies toward the Arab world?”

Now, one may quibble with many aspects of Mahameed’s opinions. I’m not sure what more the Israelis and the Europeans can do to teach Arabs and Muslims about the Holocaust, or how they would go about it in the face of the state-run, Holocaust-denying propaganda machines in many Arab states. Something tells me that a proposal to launch European- or Israeli-run Holocaust Study Centers would not be particularly welcome in most Arab and/or Muslim countries.

Such quibbles notwithstanding, Mahameed is also someone who is placing the responsibility on his fellow Arabs and Muslims to move past the Holocaust denial and the Jew-hatred so rampant in the Muslim and Arab world, and to start by confronting the reality of the Holocaust. At the time of the grotesque assemblage in Tehran, that’s a good start — particularly when the preachers of hate have their contingent of European and American enablers.

Iran’s denial of a visa to Mahameed speaks volumes, of course, about the true intent of the “scientific” conference on the Holocaust. Then again, it doesn’t tell us anything about this event that we didn’t already know.


Filed under Uncategorized

4 responses to “One Muslim voice on the Holocaust, unheard

  1. jb

    He makes some good points–Israelis, with their 6 million innocent dead, are unlikely to be moved by the deaths of a few hundred or thousand among a population that’s inflicting its own civilian casualties.

    I don’t think it’s a matter of making Israel feel persecuted–“Drive them into the sea” is inherently more persecuting than “The Holocaust didn’t happen.” It’s a matter of, in the face of “We were massacred and disposessed, we need our own state,” putting forth “You were massacred and disposessed, don’t massacre and disposess other people in turn.”

    In the Passover Seder, there is the story of how the angels rejoiced at the drowning of Pharaoh’s army, but were chided by God, who said “The work of My hand is drowning in the sea, and you want to sing hymns?” The point being, that as we celebrate one instance of one people’s deliverance from tyranny, we are hoping for the deliverance of all peoples from all tyranny, and the one is inextricable from the other. So by recognizing the Holocaust, what Palestinians would be doing is saying “You were persecuted and became free, let us do the same.”

    If the suicide bombings stopped, such a message would be very powerful.

  2. Anonymous

    One quibble – the Israelis didn’t kill anyone at Sabra and Shatila. Those were the Lebanese Filangists. The Israelis do bare some indirect responsibility for not stopping it, but lets be clear that it was Arab on Arab violence.

    That being said, this guy seems to get Jews in general, and the Israelis in particular. The idea that there are people in the world who are aching to kill your children doesn’t move folks to make “risks for peace”.

  3. Tutorialblog

    jb you´re so right to me!


    My Photocommunity

  4. Sam

    He deffinetly shows a minority view, so it seems. I think that a lot of people want to feel sympathetic over there, but are overshadowed by the hate that major “leaders” throw on them. However, it is wrong how the author labels all Muslims as “Jew haters”. That’s not true. Most Muslims around the world believe the Holocaust, hate Hitler, and are sympathetic to Jewish loss and outraged at the atrocities commited by the Nazis. But, a lot of them are also sympathetic to the fact that the Palestinians were displaced from their houses and now live in occupied territory or refugee camps, and for the select few who are lucky, the Muslims pray. It’s not right to label everybody to be the same…that’s how the Holocaust started!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s